New York City Business Group
Our mission is to help businesses in NYC manage the costs of Insurance. The New York City Business Group has addressed the insurance needs of businesses and individuals in the Staten Island NY, Brooklyn NY, New York NY, Queens NY, Nassau and Bronx NY for over 10 years.
Map & Directions
Get in Touch
  •   3971 Victory Blvd,
         Staten Island NY 10314
  •   (718) 554-3425
  •   Contact Us
open
 Home

Don’t Overpay for Medigap Insurance in NYC

Last Updated: March 7, 2017

With continually rising health care costs, purchasing a Medigap insurance policy is an important personal decision that requires careful consideration. Every policy of the same type offers the same coverage, regardless of which insurance company you choose. Therefore, it's worth shopping around to ensure that you don't end up paying too much.

The monthly premium is not the only factor to keep in mind, as some companies are notorious for rate hikes, and you may find yourself in an uncomfortable position later on down the road. By enlisting the help of a knowledgeable Medicare supplement insurance broker, you'll get the peace of mind that comes from knowing that you're making an informed decision.

  • What Is Medigap?

    Open or Close

    Medigap Policies in NYCMedicare supplemental insurance, also known as Medigap, is a type of health insurance that is designed to cover certain expenses that aren't covered by the Original Medicare Plan. In New York State, Medigaps are sold through private insurance companies, such as UnitedHealthcare (UHC). In addition to enhancing your financial security by limiting your out-of-pocket expenses, the NYS Medicare supplement plans allow you to keep your doctor and hospital and to choose your own specialists and other health care providers. This is not possible with Medicare Advantage, which forces you to use doctors that are in a particular network.

    Medigaps are designated by the letters A through N. Plan A is the core package, while Plans B, C, D, F, G, M, and N each differ according to their benefits but include all of the benefits of Plan A. Plans K and L offer catastrophic coverage only, and Plans E, H, I, and J are no longer available to new enrollees.

  • Do You Need Medigap Insurance?

    Open or Close

    Before they turn 65, or before they go on Medicare, many people have a health insurance plan that requires them to pay a coinsurance, which is usually a percentage of the service fee after the deductible has been paid. With such plans, there's an annual out-of-pocket maximum that the insured must pay before the insurance company will start paying for 100% of the covered claims for the year in question.

    With Medicare, however, there is no out-of-pocket maximum. The Original Medicare Plan covers only 80% of your health care costs, so the remaining 20% that you must pay on your own can add up over time and place you in a financially vulnerable position. Investing in a Medicare supplemental insurance policy solves this problem by covering out-of-pocket costs that aren't paid by Medicare, such as copayments and deductibles.

  • When to Enroll in Medigap

    Open or Close

    Most states have a six-month open enrollment period, but as a New York resident, you can take advantage of the state's continuous open enrollment. You're also entitled to obtain a Medigap policy without being subject to medical underwriting. In other words, the insurance companies cannot ask you intrusive questions about your health status, medical history, or claims experience to determine your eligibility or calculate your monthly premium. For this reason, New York is known as a guaranteed-issue state when it comes to Medicare supplemental insurance.

  • Medigap Premiums in NYC

    Open or Close

    New York is also a community-rated state, meaning that Medigap premiums are the same for everyone, regardless of age or health status. The premiums do, however, vary according to where you live (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or Staten Island), so your broker will ask for your zip code before showing you a list of available Medigap plans in NYC. The only other eligibility requirements are that you're already covered by Medicare Plans A and B and that you live in the service area. It may be possible to get Medigap in NYC if you're under 65, but only if you have certain disabilities (end-stage renal disease, for example) and are enrolled in Medicare Plans A and B.

    Medigap premiums in NY also vary among insurance providers, and not all companies choose to offer all plans. The New York City Business Group can quickly identify the cheapest Medicare supplement insurance for you based on your location, coverage needs, and what would make the most financial sense now and over the long term.

    Medicare Supplement Plans (NY, 2017)

    Medigaps are regulated by New York State and federal law, but insurers retain various freedoms, including the right to price their Medigap policies as they choose, as well as the right to offer only one plan or the option to offer all 14 plans (A-N).

    The bottom line is that Medicare supplemental insurance policies are standardized by the federal government, so it doesn't matter which insurance company you select in terms of what is or is not covered by a particular policy. For example, the First United American Medicare Supplement Plan G is the same as Plan G from Humana. The only difference is the price, so it pays to shop around for the best deal.

    The process can be overwhelming, though, because it's not just about comparing prices. There are other factors to consider, such as how much certain companies' premiums have changed over the years, and whether or not certain plans will be available in the future. An experienced Medigap insurance broker can analyze valuable historical data to identify the companies whose rates have gone up the least. We at the New York City Business Group do all of the leg work for you, and we do it free of charge. We also provide you with top-shelf service for the duration of your enrollment. Even if you decide to switch plans, we will continue to service your needs.

  • What Services Do We Provide?

    Open or Close

    Our service package includes first comparing Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Medigap (Medicare Supplement) and then checking to see if your doctors participate with the plan that you're considering. It's important to note that you cannot have Medicare Advantage and Medigap at the same time, so comparing the two in detail is a crucial step in the process.

    You could spend a Sunday afternoon wading through the charts at the New York State Department of Financial Services website and do your own Medigap plans comparison, but we have access to privileged information that we have compiled over many years – our own library, if you will, of Medigap and Medicare Advantage health insurance data from various sources. We'll share this information with you either in-person or over the phone. Best of all, this is a resource that will be valuable for years to come. As healthcare continues to reform, we will be there to discuss the changes and how they impact you.

    In addition to discussing the differences between Medigap and Medicare Advantage, we will check your prescriptions to confirm that they're included in the formulary list of the plan in question. Then we look at the monthly cost and present you with a doctor and Rx report. If that's agreeable to you, we complete the enrollment forms for your signature and submit your application to the insurance company. We follow up in a few days for your approval and ID #.

    After that, we're available to discuss anything with you, whether it's three weeks, three months, or three years after you enroll with us. We do not just enroll you in a plan and say, "Good luck." We're available for you for the next 30 years. For instance, you may want to call us if you have a doctor that you must see and that doctor does not participate with the plan your currently enrolled in. Our job will be to help you find a plan that this doctor participates with and help you switch plans through a special enrollment period (SEP).

    Another reason why you may want to call us is if you have an Rx that is very expensive, we can check if that Rx is cheaper on any other Part D health plan's Rx formulary list, or perhaps see if you qualify for state programs like Elderly Pharmaceutical Insurance Coverage (EPIC) or federal programs like Low Income Subsidy (LIS). We'll help you understand the benefits and guidelines of these programs and, if you qualify, help you enroll and save you hundreds of dollars on your prescriptions every month.

  • Which Medigap Policy Is the Most Popular?

    Open or Close

    Nationwide, the most popular Medigap policy is Plan F, not because it's the most comprehensive, but because the insurance broker stands to get the highest commission by recommending this policy over one that might be more appropriate for his or her client's situation. In New York State, however, the popularity of Plan F is not in line with the rest of the country. The reason for this is that the premiums in NYS are much higher than in other states, due to the state's policy that every senior resident is eligible for Medigap, no matter what his or her current health or medical history is.

    It's also important to be aware that Plan F is going away on January 1, 2020. If you get Plan F now, you'll be able to keep it when 2020 rolls around, but here's the problem: you probably won't want to keep it. In 2020, Plan F will be a so-called "closed group," meaning that the people in your area who all have Plan F through the same insurance company will be part of the same group.

    The unfortunate reality is that, as time goes on, the group will get smaller because its members will either pass away or leave the group for a different plan. As a result, insurers will have no choice but to keep raising the rates because there will be fewer premium dollars coming in to support the claims. This is exactly what happened when Plan J was taken off the market in 2010.

Which Medigap Policy Is the Best?

Just because something is popular doesn't mean that it's the best. Furthermore, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) prohibits brokers from using superlatives like "best" to describe insurance policies, so we cannot answer this question and remain compliant with CMS regulations.

While you may ask other seniors for their opinions, it's not always the best course of action to follow what other people are doing because you don't know everything about their circumstances. Therefore, it's advisable to consult with an insurance broker, who is legally obligated to give you an objective point of view.

Give us a call at (718) 554-3425, and at the click of a button, we'll be able to tell you:

  • The Medigap policies in NYC
  • Who offers them
  • How much they cost
  • Which insurers have a history of high rate increases
  • Which insurers have a history of low rate increases (some even decrease their rates from time to time, if you can believe it)

Again, all NYS Medicare supplement plans of the same letter (A-N) are identical from one carrier to the next. So, for the most part, the decision comes down to the current price of a particular plan and how the monthly premium might change over time. New York City Business Group can help you settle on a policy and ensure that you don't overpay for Medigap insurance in NYC.

We do not recommend that you buy insurance directly from the insurance company. Their job is to enroll you in the most expensive plan that their company offers, regardless of whether they know that a competitor has a plan that meets your needs for less money. After the sales rep enrolls you in the plan, you get passed off to the member services department, and you never speak to that agent again.

We don't recommend buying Medigap insurance through the mail, either. As tempting as some offers may seem, there's a reason why they're so cheap. These insurers use very low prices to get your business and later jack up the rates.

Companies that call you on the phone out of the blue are no better. They like to use high-pressure sales tactics to strong-arm you into buying a Medigap policy as soon as possible and then try to make you feel guilty if you don't give in. As a New Yorker, you have plenty of time to make this important life decision and don't need to be bullied into action to meet an enrollment deadline.

We won't call you without your permission, but we welcome you to call us at (718) 554-3425, or you may contact us by email. As brokers, we work for you, not the insurance companies. We serve seniors in all of New York State, as well as New Jersey, and we look forward to making your Medigap enrollment a painless experience.